The planetary geartrain can be reduced in size and weight, and has excellent durability since the input torque is divided by the number of planet gears when the power is transmitted. In order to improve its durability, the load sharing among planet gears must be even. However, of the various manufacturing errors possible, the carrier pinhole position error has the greatest influence on load sharing. This study compared and analyzed the load sharing and the gear safety of planetary gears, according to the phase of the carrier pinhole position error. We confirmed that load sharing among the planet gears varied, depending on the phase of the carrier pinhole position error. The mesh load factor is inversely related to the gear safety factor for bending and contact, and affects the durability of the planetary geartrain. Also, in the design of the planetary geartrain, the load sharing among planet gears is directly affected by the carrier pinhole position error and its phase. Therefore, the geometric tolerance must be managed efficiently, which needs to be reflected in the production drawings.